The Shame I Carried For Years (And Why It Wasn't Mine to Carry)

I recently came across an article that offered a fresh perspective on an experience I have carried quietly for way too long. The article is called Why Emotionally Intelligent People Struggle Most in Toxic Workplaces, by Elise Dyer, and I would encourage you to read it if any of what follows resonates.

The article names something I lived through, but struggled to accept at the time. As Elise states:

A toxic workplace is not simply a stressful one. Stress is universal. Difficulty is universal. What distinguishes toxicity is the systematic absence of psychological safety combined with the active presence of behaviours that punish honesty, suppress vulnerability, and reward performance at the expense of people. It is a place where credit is stolen quietly and blame is distributed loudly. Where feedback is weaponised rather than offered in service of growth. Where conflict is either avoided entirely or resolved through dominance rather than dialogue. Where the unspoken rules matter far more than the written ones, and the unspoken rules are frequently unkind.

Although signs of that toxicity were evident in my working environment, I ignored them, working hard to influence the development of a high-performing function and leadership team. I really thought I could make a difference, but after a series of events where poor leadership behaviour impacted me directly, my mental health deteriorated. When I shared in a meeting that I had been struggling, but had realised I was no longer coping, the manager made no mention of the business context or any of their previous actions, instead responding with blame and threat.

When I received no apology or attempt to accept any responsibility and reset the relationship, I named in writing and verbally that I no longer felt psychologically safe. This statement was ignored; no questions, no acknowledgment, not even a challenge, and of course, there was no follow-up.

Image developed using generative AI tools under the author's creative direction

For a long time, I carried shame about that experience. Shame that I had allowed myself to be treated that way, shame that I had not left sooner, shame that I had not protected myself better or taken alternative actions to hold leaders to account. I felt a sense of moral injury and then shame at not being bigger/better than that.

It took me years and a lot of work to accept that I was not responsible for how others chose to behave, including those who turned a blind eye, that the erosion of safety was not something I caused, and the punitive response to naming it was not something I deserved.

What helped me process and integrate that experience was a deliberately developmental approach, using a range of practices including developmental coaching, that created space for me to acknowledge my feelings and get genuinely curious about what had happened. Without having the framework or language for it at the time, I was working in what I now recognise as a contrasting emotions space, holding the difficult emotions alongside curiosity rather than letting them consume me. Over time that distance allowed me to see things I could not see while I was living it.

I gained significant insights around identity; about who I had been trying to be in that environment, what I had believed I needed to prove, and how much of my self-worth I had tied to being able to fix something that was never mine to fix.

The developmental work did not erase what happened, but it gave me a way to hold it without being defined by it.

Elise's article also offered an additional perspective around why emotionally intelligent people suffer more in toxic environments, not less. The very qualities that make someone a thoughtful colleague and effective leader; the capacity to notice shifts in tone, to absorb the emotional climate and to believe things can be better, become sources of pain rather than protection, when the culture is dysfunctional. The article helped me see how my own depth of awareness, which had served me well in healthy environments, left me exposed in a culture that rewarded blind loyalty.

One thing from the article that has stayed with me is the idea that emotionally intelligent people are not the most fragile members of a team. When given the right conditions, they are its greatest asset. They simply cannot flourish in the dark and I suspect there are more people working in the dark than we acknowledge, particularly as the pressure on leaders intensifies with AI transformation and the impact of our Brittle, Anxious, Non-linear and Incomprehensible (BANI) world.

The piece on compassionate leadership in the article also really resonated with me. I have long believed that compassionate leadership is often misread as weakness in results-oriented cultures, as though care and performance are somehow opposed to each other. As the article points out, compassionate leadership is not about being lenient or excessively accommodating.

Compassionate Leadership creates the conditions in which people can be honest about what is hard, which turns out to be exactly what is required for genuine problem-solving, innovation, sustained performance and navigating complexity

Organisations that bypass that step, demanding performance while neglecting the human conditions that make it possible, often find themselves with what looks on the surface to be a retention problem, but is actually a leadership problem.

If you are in something similar right now, or if you have been and are still making sense of it, I hope this article helps you recognise that your struggle is not a sign of weakness. It is evidence that your capacity for emotional depth is real, and that it deserves to be in a context that honours it rather than exploits it.

I am most grateful to Elise Dyer for this important article and to Kelly-Ann James who kindly shared it.

The original version of this article was first published on LinkedIn on 05 August 2026.

Previous
Previous

Culture as capacity. What becomes possible?

Next
Next

The Bridge Between Horizontal and Vertical Development: A Conversation with an AI Coaching Mentor